Abnormality: the Only Normal

Abnormality: the Only Normal

It’s almost like Carol Ann Duffy doesn’t want us to read her poems. From the beginning, they’re obscure and discomforting.

Open the book, provocatively titled Standing Female Nude, and you first encounter Pakistan. You may not know that, of course. I didn’t at first. The first two poems allude often to Islam, which doesn’t narrow down the geography much. The clearest references to Pakistan are two villages and a city—Dina, Jhang Chak, Jhelum. I looked them up and found a triad of communities in the northeast of the country, near a volatile and complicated border zone shared with India.

Then suddenly Pakistan and Islam fade into nonexistence, reappearing only in veiled allusions like in “A Healthy Meal,” which wonders about the “secret dreams of cows” and asserts, “The woman chewing suckling pig / must sleep with her husband later.” I’m reminded of the laws against pork in both Jewish and Islamic culture and the ritual impurity of both eating pig and sexual activity. The Semitic allusions reappear in other poems. They are part of the fabric of English life, yet often unwelcome at the haughty feast of Western society.

I see this theme unfolding as attention to folks on the fringe of mainstream Western European society. Besides the Jews and Muslims, there are criminals (“Lizzie, Six”), drug addicts (“Someone Else’s Daughter”), sociopaths (“Education for Leisure”) and murderers (“Human Interest”), foreigners (“Free Will” and “Alliance”). They are voices of the dispossessed, the vagabonds, the outcasts. What about the rest of the collection? Most of it seems to describe a typical modern British life, familiar to most of her audience. But I think she shows us we’re just as much outcasts, no matter who we are. Norms are illusions, impossible measuring sticks. The romantic and family relationships in Duffy’s poems reveal our clumsy attempts to bridge the isolation we all feel. Being human is being abnormal.

Sources:

Duffy, Carol Ann. Standing Female Nude. Anvil Press Poetry, 1985.

Image: Omar Alnahi on Pexels.com.

4 Replies to “Abnormality: the Only Normal”

  1. While I can agree that many of Duffy’s poems are offputting in their sometimes discomforting content, I have to disagree with you on the assertion that Duffy is intentionally making her poems difficult to relate to by focusing on obscure and unrelatable topics. Percy Shelley once described poets as the “unassigned legislators of the world,” and this is a role I feel Duffy readily assumes. No topic is too stigmatized and no perspective is too distant that Duffy will not attempt to embrace it with a poem, because Duffy writes about the world as it is, through any and all perspectives. While she may intentionally delve into uncomfortable subjects, at no point did I feel that Duffy was writing about something with the intent to repel the reader.

    1. I’m with Chris: I don’t think that Duffy doesn’t want us to not read her poems. But I do think she wants to make us work and think about the subjects that she is tackling. I took a class with someone once who encouraged us to think about poetry in terms of “why did the author choose to put this in a poem rather than in prose.” Duffy wants to talk about these things, so she writes a poem; but what is the poem supposed to do, as Tara asks below.

  2. I like that you point out that we are all outcasts. I definitely agree with this, we are all outcasts in our own ways – some of which we don’t enjoy sharing. Why do you think she sends this message with her poems? What is she saying about society as a whole while deciding to write about outcasts and make people uncomfortable? What do you believe is her overarching goal? Just to point it out? or get people to take action?

  3. I liked, Dane, that you just provided a neat list of the various individual representatives of various subcultures that are present in Duffy’s poetry. One source on Duffy I read described her as a poet that gives a voice to a whole variety of obscure people. Thinking about it this way however, makes me a little mad. To me if this was the case then there seems to be more rotten voices then there should. Poetry is not always suppose to light and fluffy; it’s a great medium to convey feelings of darkness and just wrongness. I guess what I’m trying to say here is that I wish there were others who Duffy would give a voice to.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

css.php